The report card is out: Chaos in Iraq is 'irreversible' - Instablogs
The report card is out: Chaos in Iraq is 'irreversible'
Naresh Chauhan , Shimla: Jul 13 2007
Made Popular Jul 13 2007

The report card is out: Chaos in Iraq is 'irreversible'How to best describe the situation in Iraq? Whether call it worse or a nightmare, one thing is clear that the situation is ‘irreversible.’ Iraq has surpassed every standard of cruelty, bloodshed and factionalism - this all in the name of bringing peace, stability and democracy. However, the most appalling aspect of the war has been its ever changing definition, tricky promises and President Bush’s stubbornness to embrace any of the key recommendations.

President Bush may have expressed satisfaction on Maliki’s administration and optimism over the way things have gone in Iraq ignoring the hard hitting fact mentioned by CIA Director Michael V. Hayden last year that ‘the inability of the government to govern seems irreversible‘ and that there is no ‘point to any milestone or checkpoint where we can turn this thing around.’

Needless to go in details of what caused Hayden to use such a harsh tongue to express the works and administration of Nouri al-Maliki in Iraq? The Iraqi government over the period, since it was formed in December 2005 under Maliki, has failed on many (in fact all) fronts, such as economic, offering public services, military, fostering reconciliation among different factions and so on.

Current U.S. strategy, the New Way Forward, just fails to move forward and fulfill the commitments - a democratic Iraq that can govern, defend, and sustain itself - made by both the U.S. and Iraqi Governments. While the Iraqi Government falls short of its preset objectives and failed at every step, at the same time, the US also failed to build a strong strategic partnership with the Iraqi Government, paving the way for further chaos.

Now, after four years of continuous struggle, it looks as if the US is caught in a situation from where Bush sees the (Iraq) glass half full, while others see it half empty, but the reality, as put forth by the CIA Director, shows a glass that’s bone dry. Such facts are, however, kept hidden in Bush’s dirty closet, to be revealed after precious time has lapsed. This makes one ponder that how many lies are to be witnessed before US actually starts withdrawing its troops leaving behind a mess for the future generations to clean.

Even after the CIA report last year Bush’s ‘Churchillian’ vision of ‘victory’ in Iraq never seems to make tracks. Bush’s ‘real debate’ shifts (time and again) over Iraq and Democrats too are no exception. However, as the report card on Iraq war is out and out of 18 US-set benchmarks Iraq has satisfactorily met eight, hasn’t satisfactorily met eight others and made mixed progress on two, which shifts the (relevant and most important) debate away from U.S. troop levels to one about winning and losing.

The failure and inability of the Maliki government is not a matter of concern for only the US and Iraqi administration but different people and human rights organizations across the world. For the breakdown of Iraqi government, which just appears inevitable, may prompt ethnic re-cleansing and encourage different factions for coercive reversals of ethnic cleansings, widespread in Saddam’s regime.

No doubt, at present, the chaotic situation in Iraq looks irreversible and the credit goes to Bush administration (at the forefront) and the Maliki government (at the backdrop). Iraqi government has lost its credibility, which was always at the stake since it was formed in 2005, but the conditions (present) in Iraq have hurt US, landing a jab on its credibility (worldwide) that for sure seems ‘irreversible’ as is the case with Iraq.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
It’s so obvious that Iraq is a mess. After the revelation that chaos in Iraq is ‘irreversible,’ now, Bush can’t say that the situation in Iraq is under control?

So many lies have now been told by the Bush administration that it is difficult to find the truth, and as usual until truth is found and accepted, there can be no way forward and future of Iraq looks bleak.
0 Stars
Yea, Mr. Naresh I think you are right when you say Chaos in Iraq is ‘irreversible
2 Stars
War in Iraq has reached a point where retreating would be a disaster. If the US steps back from Iraq today, different Islamic factions would die battling each other.

Iraq, at present, just looks a lost cause and an utter failure, but, silly people (like Bush) in the US are still dreaming of glory.
1 Stars
Gagandeep
Shimla, India
Is this supposed to be a joke? ‘Irreversible,’ how convenient? Does the truth absolve you of all your misdoings or does it make you even more liable? Can the Americans just cut and run now that they have declared loud and clear that the chaos in Iraq is beyond any help? What happened to all those promises that the US will leave Iraq in a better shape than it was under Saddam Hussein? American good-intentions or lack thereof? American security or peace and stability in the Middle East, in particular, and World, in general? Bush’s loss of face or is it sheer hopelessness for Iraqi populace?

The list of questions is unfortunately, endless. The answers, I’m afraid are limited…
3 Stars
This is not a joke. This is just another example of what happens when US makes commitment. You gotta be dumb if u still remember those promises of US to make this world a better place that were empty at the first place.

Its ‘war on terror’ is nothing but a means to justify its back-up to its political and economic interests.

The presence of American forces overseas reflects the need for the US to project visible and psychological presence and commitment to a country or region. Following the logic of neocolonialism, US bases are a stark reminder and real source of control over a nation without necessitating formal political control over its territorial sovereignty. Its mere presence intimidates and gives coercive power for the US to gain concessions from the host and allows it to interfere, in most cases with impunity, in internal affairs, commit crimes and violence on the native people.
1 Stars
The situation in Iraq has seriously reached a point of no return – Bush took his nation into a war for which there was never any justification, and today the situation is such - a decision to withdraw means, collapse of the American empire, and staying in Iraq only speeds up its collapse.

America fears, retreat form middle east would mean more bloodshed – but in my view, the situation in Iraq and Middle East is such that even good intent from the US will fall inappropriate to solve the catastrophe. America has become a country that can only add fire (start) to international crises but can in no way solve.
1 Stars
Arjun
NCR, India
Iraq war is not the first war where USA has found itself in some quagmire. So stop having the chimera that ”collapse of the American Dream” is going to come.

But yeah, now some other people may have to sacrifice their lives for USA’s interests. It won;t be a surprise if tomorrow UN comply with US’s demand of having UN forces in Iraq, seeing the present ’need’ of the country.
What better soldiers can they have than from Indian Sub-continent or other developing countries? Here people are in abundance, and lure of having salary in dollars will be big enough to see high enrollment of Pakistan’s soldiers. And of course their being Muslim can be for first time prove to be an advantage.

But please stop dreaming that US Empire has been hit bad from the war. They have got what they wanted.
Add your Comment